Are your trust distributions to grandparents at risk under Section 100A?

.

When distributing trust income to grandparents, who may often be retired or on a lower income, there are tax considerations to keep in mind, especially under section 100A of the Income Tax Assessment Act. This section is particularly relevant when the grandparents, as beneficiaries, may not fully benefit from the income allocated to them. If the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) deems the distributions to be part of a reimbursement agreement, where the income is redirected to other family members or entities, the trust’s taxable income could be adjusted, potentially resulting in additional tax liabilities.

To comply with tax laws and avoid penalties, it’s essential that trust distributions provide a real and genuine benefit to the grandparents. Trustees should ensure the distributions are not simply a means to reduce tax by taking advantage of the grandparents’ lower marginal tax rate. The trust deed should clearly support the grandparents’ entitlement to the income, and any related financial transactions should reflect a genuine commercial dealing. Trust distributions that involve capital gains or net income should be approached cautiously, as missteps could trigger compliance actions by the ATO.

Given the complexity of Section 100A and the risks associated with reimbursement agreements, it’s advisable to seek professional guidance. Book a consultation today for tailored advice that suits your needs.

Could grandparents’ gifts or loans from trust distributions trigger section 100A?

When grandparents use their trust distributions to provide gifts or loans to other family members, it’s important to consider the potential implications under Section 100A of the Income Tax Assessment Act. This section may apply if the arrangement appears to be a strategy for reducing taxes, particularly when the grandparents are on a lower marginal tax rate and the funds are passed on to family members on higher tax rates.

However, if a grandparent gives a gift without any intention to reduce tax, Section 100A may not apply. Taxpayers might argue that these gifts are made based on ordinary family objectives, not as part of any arrangement linked to the initial trust distribution entitlement. Whether the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) views the transaction as high-risk depends on factors like the frequency and nature of the gifts.

One-time gifts

If a grandparent uses a trust distribution to make a one-time gift to a family member, it’s less likely that Section 100A will apply. These transactions can be explained by family traditions or objectives, especially if there was no pre-arranged plan to pass on the funds when the grandparent became entitled to the distribution.

Recurring gifts or loans

In contrast, if the grandparent repeatedly uses trust distributions to gift or loan money to family members on higher tax rates, the ATO may view this as a tax avoidance arrangement. Regular gifts or loans might suggest an intent to reduce the overall family tax burden, making them more likely to attract scrutiny under Section 100A.

Given the complexity of these rules, it’s advisable to seek professional advice to ensure your trust arrangements comply with tax laws and do not inadvertently trigger Section 100A.

Could paying your grandchild’s private school fees with trust distributions trigger section 100A?

When grandparents use trust distributions to pay for their grandchild’s private school fees, there are potential risks under section 100A of the Income Tax Assessment Act. Private school fees are generally considered a parental responsibility, typically covered by the parents, who may also be the controllers of the trust. If the distribution intended for the grandparent is used to cover these expenses, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) might view this as a situation where the economic benefit flows to the parents rather than the grandparent, raising concerns under section 100A.

The ATO has indicated that the risk level under section 100A depends on the specific facts of each case. While some arrangements may be low-risk, others could be considered high-risk or contrived, especially if they suggest a tax reduction motive.

Recurring arrangements

If the grandparent regularly uses trust distributions to pay for school fees, the ATO might consider this a tax avoidance strategy, particularly if the payments appear to be part of a pre-arranged plan between the parents and grandparents. This recurring pattern could imply that the grandparent’s entitlement is being redirected for the parents’ benefit, triggering section 100A.

Financial dependence

If the grandparent relies solely on the trust distribution to pay these fees and has little or no other means of financial support, this could raise questions about the legitimacy of the arrangement. The ATO may scrutinise such cases more closely, especially if the grandparent is not financially independent.

Passive involvement

If the grandparent has minimal involvement in the trust and is merely a passive recipient of the distribution, the ATO might view this as a high-risk scenario. In such cases, the ATO could consider the arrangement contrived, potentially leading to adjustments to the trust’s tax obligations under section 100A.

Given the complexities of these situations, it’s important to seek professional advice to ensure your trust distributions comply with tax laws and don’t inadvertently trigger section 100A.

What exclusions protect trust distributions from section 100A?

When evaluating whether a trust distribution might be subject to Section 100A of the Income Tax Assessment Act, it’s important to consider certain key exclusions that can prevent the distribution from being invalidated. If any of these exclusions apply, Section 100A will not impact the validity of the trust distribution.

Beneficiary under a legal disability

Section 100A does not apply to trust distributions made to beneficiaries under a legal disability, such as minors or bankrupt individuals. In these cases, the trust income is assessed to the trustee on behalf of the beneficiary under Section 98. Since the beneficiary’s entitlement to the trust income arises without any intention to reduce tax, Section 100A does not apply. Unless specifically stated in the trust deed, references to beneficiaries generally assume they are not under a legal disability.

No tax reduction purpose

Another exclusion applies when the trust distribution is part of a reimbursement agreement or commercial dealing that was not entered into with a tax reduction purpose. A tax reduction purpose involves ensuring that a person, whether involved in the agreement or not, pays no income tax or less tax than would have been payable if the distribution had been made to the person who truly benefited from it. Even if a tax reduction purpose is not the primary or sole reason for the arrangement, Section 100A can still apply unless it can be demonstrated that the distribution was made with genuine consideration and provided real economic benefit to the beneficiary.

Understanding these exclusions is crucial for ensuring that your trust distributions are compliant with tax laws and protected from being invalidated under Section 100A.

Why Section 100A is unlikely to apply to distributions made to trust controllers

Section 100A of the Income Tax Assessment Act is generally not applicable to trust distributions made to the controllers of the trust or their spouses. These individuals, often the primary beneficiaries, usually receive and use the distributions directly. This direct alignment between benefit and distribution reduces the likelihood of a Section 100A challenge.

Additionally, since controllers typically pay tax at higher marginal rates, there is no tax reduction purpose behind these distributions. Without a tax avoidance motive, such distributions are less likely to be classified as high-risk under Section 100A.

In cases where controllers retain their trust entitlements within the trust for purposes like working capital or reinvestment, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) considers these arrangements low-risk if they involve genuine commercial dealings. As long as these retained amounts are appropriately managed, the risk of Section 100A applying remains minimal.

For more insights on how Section 100A affects trust distributions, particularly those involving adult children, we recommend exploring our detailed article titled “What Common Trust Distributions to Adult Children Can Be Attacked Under Section 100A?“

TMS Financials provides you with a team of experienced professionals that help you achieve your financial goals through smart tax structures and strategic financial structuring. We’re a one-stop shop for all financial needs and pride ourselves on building strong partnerships with our clients.

Book a free financial health review to see the difference we can make in your financial future.

This outline is for general information only and not as legal, tax or accounting advice. It may not be accurate, complete or current. It is not official and not from a government institution. Always consult a qualified professional for specific advice tailored to your unique circumstances.